Shirimono Logo
Shirimono
GRAMMAR
〜ならともかく
it's one thing if ~, but ~
Explanation
NOTE

〜ならともかく means it's one thing if ~, but ~ — used to contrast an acceptable case with an unacceptable one.

子供こどもならともかく、大人おとながそんなことをするなんて。
It's one thing if it's a child, but for an adult to do such a thing...
The first item is tolerable; the second (the topic of the main clause) is not.
NOTE

The main clause usually expresses surprise, criticism, or complaint about the second item.

NOTE

Mainly attached to nouns; the meaning is if it were ~, fine, but... (学生 → 学生ならともかく).

STRUCTURE
N辞
ならともかく
1いち日にちならともかくならともかく、1いっ週しゅう間かんもも休やすむのは困こまります。
Ichinichi naratomokaku, isshuukan mo yasumu no wa komarimasu.
If it's for one day, that's fine, but taking a week off is a problem.
少すこし高たかい物ものならともかくならともかく、家いえを買かうのは無理むりです。
Sukoshi takai mono naratomokaku, ie o kau no wa muri desu.
If it were a slightly expensive item, that would be okay, but buying a house is impossible.
私わたしならともかくならともかく、彼かれにはまだ早はやすぎます。
Watashi naratomokaku, kare ni wa mada hayasugimasu.
If it were me, that would be one thing, but it's still too early for him.
新人しんじんならともかく、ベテランがそんなミスをするとは。
Shinjin nara tomokaku, beteran ga sonna misu o suru to wa.
It's one thing if it's a newcomer, but for a veteran to make such a mistake...
無料むりょうならともかく、こんなに高たかくては買かえない。
Muryou nara tomokaku, konna ni takakute wa kaenai.
It's one thing if it were free, but at this price I can't buy it.
昔むかしならともかく、今いまはそんな習慣しゅうかんはない。
Mukashi nara tomokaku, ima wa sonna shuukan wa nai.
It's one thing if it were the old days, but there's no such custom now.

Practice exercises

1
万まんが一いち、子供こどもならともかく、大人おとなは許ゆるされない。
If it were a child, it would be one thing, but an adult cannot be forgiven, even in the unlikely event.
Answer
ならともかく
2
小ちいさなミスならともかく、重大じゅうだいな問題もんだいが起おきる様ようでは、許ゆるされない。
If it's a small mistake, it's one thing, but if a serious problem were to occur, it wouldn't be forgivable.
Answer
ならともかく
3
単たんなる誤解ごかいならともかく、これは明あきらかに意図的いとてきな行為こういだ。
If it's just a simple misunderstanding, it's one thing, but this is clearly an intentional act.
Answer
ならともかく
4
机上きじょうの空論くうろんならともかく、現実的げんじつてきな対策たいさくが必要ひつようだ。
If it's just a theoretical argument, it's one thing, but concrete measures are needed.
Answer
ならともかく
5
緊急時きんきゅうじならともかく、普段ふだんに使つかうものなら、事故じこが起おきるぞ。
If it's an emergency, it's one thing, but if you were to use it normally, an accident would happen!
Answer
ならともかく